
Ten years ago, there were very few papers about immersive or maladaptive daydreaming in the academic literature. Now the ICMDR website lists well over a hundred peer-reviewed studies. Researchers from all over the world publish new articles every month.
Before they can study any aspect of maladaptive daydreaming, researchers need to find people who experience it. That means they need to define what maladaptive daydreaming is and be able to measure whether someone has it.
How do researchers measure maladaptive daydreaming?
There are two parts to maladaptive daydreaming – first, you have to be able to immersively daydream, and, second, your daydreaming has to be so intrusive or excessive that it’s causing problems. It is the difficulties caused by daydreaming that make it maladaptive.
Most studies of maladaptive daydreaming use the MDS-16 to identify maladaptive daydreamers. The MDS-16 asks questions such as “How much does your daydreaming interfere with your ability to get basic chores accomplished?” and “How much does your daydreaming interfere with your academic/occupational success?”. It focusses on the problems caused by excessive daydreaming, and therefore does a good job of identifying whether someone’s daydreaming is harming them.
What the MDS-16 doesn’t do so well is check that someone is an immersive daydreamer. Researchers using the MDS-16 don’t always define what they mean by “daydreaming”. They assume that study participants will define daydreaming in the same way they do.
Daydreaming is not well defined
The word daydreaming means different things to different people. Many people who never immersively daydream use the terms daydreaming and mind wandering interchangeably. And because immersive and maladaptive daydreaming haven’t been well studied until recently, researchers have accidentally added to the confusion.
Some studies define mind wandering as any thought that isn‘t connected to what you‘re doing in that moment. By that definition, immersive daydreaming would be a type of mind wandering. Some people who struggle to focus may think their excessive mind wandering counts as daydreaming and could therefore score highly on the MDS-16 despite not experiencing maladaptive daydreaming. When researchers don’t clearly define what counts as daydreaming for the purposes of their study, they can’t be sure that their participants will define daydreaming in the same way they do.
A new questionnaire could change this
A new article by Nitzan Theodor-Katz and Nirit Soffer-Dudek tries to clear up some of this confusion by introducing a questionnaire called the Daydreaming Characteristics Questionnaire (DCQ), which can be used alongside the MDS-16 in studies of maladaptive daydreaming. The DCQ can assess whether someone is an immersive daydreamer. The MDS-16 then measures whether that immersive daydreaming has become maladaptive.
The DCQ asks about the common features of immersive daydreaming. It includes questions about whether daydreams are vivid, unrealistic and have a repetitive theme, and whether there is a continuous narrative, and rich and positive emotional content. These features quickly and easily distinguish immersive daydreaming from mind wandering.
So far, the DCQ has only been tested in Hebrew and all the study participants were from Israel. Further research will be needed to confirm that the questionnaire works in other languages and in other parts of the world. A cutoff score beyond which someone would be considered an immersive daydreamer hasn’t been established. And researchers don’t know how well the questionnaire will work in people with mental health problems. But even with all of those limitations, this is an important step towards recognising that not everybody daydreams.
I hope that the DCQ will become an integral part of maladaptive daydreaming studies, alongside the MDS-16. Checking that study participants experience immersive daydreaming rather than excessive mind wandering removes a possible source of uncertainty in study results. The conclusions that researchers draw about maladaptive daydreaming from questionnaire-based studies would become more reliable.
This questionnaire could also help maladaptive daydreamers
I’d also like to see the DCQ used by therapists. Many maladaptive daydreamers struggle to describe their daydreaming to a therapist. Others are afraid to try in case the therapist asks them about their plot or characters.
Several decades ago, when I first went to therapy, my therapist didn’t ask what I was thinking about when I got distracted. But if they had, I wouldn’t have disclosed the contents of my daydreams. It would have been too embarrassing. I’d probably have mumbled something like “Oh, I’m not really sure. Nothing important”. And my therapist would have assumed that I was mind wandering, just like all their other clients. That’s one of the problems with maladaptive daydreaming. Most of us find it difficult to talk about what goes on in our minds, even in therapy.
But what if we could explain to a therapist how we daydream, without having to say what we daydream about? That’s something the DCQ could allow us to do. I hope that one day, therapists will hand new clients a copy of the DCQ. Then, simply by circling a few numbers, maladaptive daydreamers can show that their daydreaming is deeper and more complex than simple mind wandering, in a way that the therapist can understand and which doesn’t cause embarrassment to the daydreamer. Wouldn’t that make therapy so much easier for all of us?
[Photo by Pavel Danilyuk]



