
In 2017, a study of 39 maladaptive daydreamers found that ALL of them met the criteria for at least one mental-health disorder. Nearly three-quarters met the criteria for at least three. Although 39 is a small sample size for a study of this type, the results fit with the stories I see on social media. For most maladaptive daydreamers, their excessive daydreaming is not the only problem they have.
Why do so many maladaptive daydreamers have poor mental health? I can think of three possible explanations:
Maladaptive daydreamers are being misdiagnosed with problems they don’t have
Maladaptive daydreaming causes very real suffering, but it is not yet formally recognised in the DSM. Diagnosis is the first step in treating any mental-health problem. Doctors need to understand what someone is suffering from before they can work out how best to treat them.
Sometimes, doctors dismiss the concerns of maladaptive daydreamers by saying that “everybody daydreams”. But sometimes the reverse happens. Doctors see genuine suffering and feel a need to diagnose a patient with something. Often, that means picking the DSM diagnosis that comes closest to describing the patient’s experience, even if it doesn’t fit exactly.
Maladaptive daydreaming causes other mental-health problems
Spending many hours each day lost in fantasy has consequences, especially if it’s been your default thinking style from a young age. A child who chooses their imaginary friends over their peers doesn’t learn social skills. That can lead to social anxiety and social isolation in later years.
Living in your head rather than in reality means that, over time, you will fall behind your peers who spend all their time in the real world. That leads to under-achievement and negative social comparisons. Which, in turn, can lead to feelings of not being good enough. And that can manifest as low self-esteem or depression.
Knowing that your brain works differently from other people’s can lead to shame, which can be a trigger for a range of mental-health problems.
Mental-health problems cause maladaptive daydreaming
Mental-health problems, by definition, involve unpleasant thoughts and feelings. A mental-health problem is not an easy thing to live with. It’s not a situation you can take yourself away from. It’s a state of being that follows you around. Most of the time you just want to not be you.
If you’re an immersive daydreamer, you have a built-in way to escape from being you. In your daydreams you can visit a world where you literally don’t exist. Or you might prefer to daydream about being someone else. Or you daydream about a version of you that doesn’t have your mental-health problem. We have a range of options for getting away from our real-world selves.
When you have a mental-health problem that means you’re not comfortable with who you are in real life, it’s almost inevitable that you will become addicted to your daydreams. They’re probably the only place you feel peace. Your maladaptive daydreaming is your attempt to temporarily feel a little better, even if it makes your life worse in the long-term.
In conclusion
All the above possibilities probably explain the connection between maladaptive daydreaming and poor mental health in some people. But I think the last one may be the most common.
A study published in 2023 suggested that 50% of us will experience poor mental health by the age of 75. If you are an immersive daydreamer and you are living with poor mental health, the temptation to turn to your daydreaming as a way to escape from your negative thoughts and feelings will be overwhelming. If it’s the only way you can cope with those thoughts and feelings, your immersive daydreaming will quickly become maladaptive.
Immersive daydreamers who are lucky enough to avoid mental-health problems don’t need to use their daydreaming as an escape. They will therefore find it easier to balance daydreaming and real life. And that means they will probably remain immersive daydreamers.
If your maladaptive daydreaming was caused by an underlying mental-health problem, then your daydreaming is not the reason you feel bad; it’s the way you’re trying to cope with feeling bad. Stopping maladaptive daydreaming will take away your coping mechanism without addressing the underlying problem. It will therefore leave you feeling worse.
If you’ve been self-medicating your depression or anxiety by daydreaming, please talk to your doctor to get the underlying problem appropriately diagnosed and treated. If you are living with both maladaptive daydreaming and poor mental health, you are fighting two battles. Just because your doctor doesn’t understand the first one (or you’re too embarrassed to tell them) doesn’t mean they can’t help you with the second one. You do not have to deal with this alone.
Stay safe. Reach out for help if you need it.
[Photo by Karel Drozda]



