Should maladaptive daydreaming be in the DSM?

In an earlier post, I looked at why maladaptive daydreaming isn’t in the DSM. But in this post, I want to take a step back and ask a controversial question: should maladaptive daydreaming be included in the DSM?

Arguments in favour of inclusion:
A real diagnosis

Including maladaptive daydreaming in the DSM would officially recognise a disorder that too many mental-health professionals remain unaware of. It would make the condition real. Therapists would have to take it seriously. No more suggesting that it’s “something everyone does” or that it’s “not that harmful”. There would be acknowledgement that maladaptive daydreaming causes real suffering, and that those who experience it are just as deserving of help and support as anyone else who suffers from a mental-health problem.

An official definition

If maladaptive daydreaming were included in the DSM, researchers would have to agree on exactly what it is. There would be clear diagnostic criteria. And, as with other mental-health disorders, those criteria would almost certainly include distress and dysfunction. That would draw a clear line between harmful maladaptive daydreaming and healthy immersive daydreaming. It would make it easier to push back against anyone who claims that having stories in your head automatically means you’re mentally ill.

Fewer daydreamers would be misdiagnosed

Maladaptive daydreaming stops people from living happy, functional lives. When a psychiatrist sees a patient who is suffering, they want to be able to diagnose them with something, so that they can get help and support. But at the moment, there isn’t a diagnosis that fully describes the patient’s symptoms. So psychiatrists try to put them into other boxes. It’s possible that some daydreamers have been misdiagnosed with ADHD, and a recent case report describes a young man whose childhood daydreaming led to a misdiagnosis of autism that was not uncovered until he was an adult.

Arguments against inclusion:
A diagnosis could overlook the underlying issue

Maladaptive daydreaming is commonly a coping mechanism. That means there is an underlying issue the daydreamer is coping with. Often, that underlying issue is another mental-health problem. One study of 39 maladaptive daydreamers found that all of them had at least one additional diagnosis. Treating that underlying problem is often the key to healing maladaptive daydreaming. Diagnosing someone with maladaptive daydreaming might make it more likely that the underlying issue is overlooked.

A diagnosis could take away hope and agency

If you see maladaptive daydreaming as a coping mechanism that’s got out of control, there’s an implicit assumption that you might be able to regain control. But if you make it a mental-health diagnosis, there’s a risk of it becoming a label that sticks. You might assume that you need the support of a doctor or therapist to get better. That’s a problem if you live in a part of the world where access to therapy is limited.

Additionally, a lot of mental-health professionals believe that diagnoses never fully go away. Instead of talking about healing and cure, they talk about managing and learning to live with. That just reinforces the idea that someone with maladaptive daydreaming will never be able to thrive in the real world.

A diagnosis might lead to treatment you aren’t ready for

Maladaptive daydreaming often starts in childhood. Realistically, it would usually be parents who would notice concerning symptoms in their child and take them to a mental-health professional for diagnosis and treatment. I’m glad that wasn’t an option when I was a child. Daydreaming was all I knew. I didn’t have the maturity to see how much it was harming me. If someone had told me that “socially isolating yourself because you prefer to daydream is bad”, I would have heard “daydreaming is bad”. It would have caused more problems than it solved. I needed to heal at a time that was right for me, not a time that was right for my parents, my teachers or my doctors.

Should maladaptive daydreaming be in the DSM?

The inclusion of maladaptive daydreaming in the DSM would lead to a shift in attitudes towards the condition. Given that it’s such a significant issue, I’m surprisingly ambivalent about it. I think all the above points, both for and against, are valid.

What I do believe, is that inclusion in the DSM will happen eventually. It may still be years away, but awareness of maladaptive daydreaming will increase, research will expand our knowledge of what maladaptive daydreaming is, and official recognition is the logical result of that. I just hope that by the time it happens, mental-health professionals will be more accepting of the idea that mental-health problems can be cured, and more open to digging below the diagnosis to target treatments at the root cause.