
Someone once asked me whether I thought that daydreaming, by itself, could be so rewarding and enjoyable that you could become addicted to it in the absence of any trauma. In other words, could daydreaming pull you in to the point where it becomes maladaptive even if you’re not using it as a coping mechanism and don’t have anything in real life that you’re trying to escape from?
I find that question difficult to answer because everyone has some stress in their life. We all face situations we wouldn’t have chosen. We all get busy and tired and come into conflict with other people. It’s hard to imagine a situation where there is genuinely nothing to escape from.
But what if we’re escaping to our daydreams?
One of the main reasons I daydream is that I want more. I want to know more, do more and experience more than is possible for one human being in one lifetime. And daydreaming gives me that.
Even if I had the best life I could possibly have in the real world, I would still daydream. Because there will always be things I want that the real world can’t give me.
The line between a want and a need
One of the things that distinguishes immersive daydreaming from maladaptive daydreaming is that immersive daydreamers daydream because they want to, whereas maladaptive daydreamers daydream because they need to. But what exactly constitutes a need?
Since I healed from maladaptive daydreaming, I no longer feel that uncontrollable urge to shut out the real world and sink into a daydream. If I’m busy, I can go a day, or even several days, without daydreaming. But could I go several weeks, or several months? I suspect not. And even if I could, I’m certain it would make me miserable.
I don’t need to daydream as a coping mechanism in the way many maladaptive daydreamers do. But I do need daydreaming to be part of my life. I wouldn’t be me without it. And not being true to yourself is one of the surest routes to unhappiness.
Do all daydreamers want more than real life can provide?
I don’t know which came first, my daydreaming or my hunger for more. But I can see how they feed on each other. For as long as I can remember, my daydreaming has allowed me to experience more. Maybe I didn’t train myself to want it, but I trained myself to believe I could have it.
Everyone wants things they can’t have. Non-daydreamers learn to accept the disappointment that comes with not getting what you want. But if I want something I can’t have, I daydream about having it, and it’s almost as good. Maybe over time, I naturally wanted more and more, because nothing was ever completely out of reach.
In real life we settle for what’s possible
For years, I stayed in a job that didn’t excite me or challenge me. It was OK. I didn’t hate it. But a lot of the time it was annoying or boring. I stayed in that job because it was a flexible, work-from-home job that fitted around the needs of my family. I accepted the lack of challenge because I was grateful for the convenience. In other words, I settled.
Then, I had a serious mental-health crisis that ended my career overnight. And my daydream partner told me to become a writer. It’s the most beautiful, fulfilling thing I’ve ever done. I’m finally doing work that feels completely aligned with the core of who I am.
I’m lucky. Not many people get to spend every single day doing work that they love. Most people settle for a job because it’s what they could get, or because it pays the bills or because it fits around their caring responsibilities.
It’s probably the same in relationships. I was lucky. I’ve been married for nearly 30 years to someone I love very much. But how many people settle for less than they deserve because they’re afraid of ending up alone?
Could settling too much lead to maladaptive daydreaming?
To come back to the original question: could daydreaming become maladaptive if it’s not an escape or a coping mechanism? Maybe.
I can’t imagine getting sucked back into maladaptive daydreaming, because I have too much in real life to stay present for. But what if I didn’t? What if I were living alone, stuck in a boring, unfulfilling job because I needed it to pay the bills?
That’s the reality for a lot of people. You do what you need to do to get by, and it doesn’t leave any time to pursue the things that nourish your soul. You settle for far less than you want, because you don’t have a choice. The life that society hands out to many of us is a life that’s largely devoid of meaning.
And so we seek meaning in our daydreams. Maybe you call it excitement, adventure or deep connection. If it’s missing from real life, you will seek it in your daydreams.
If the only place you find meaning is in your daydreams, could that, by itself, make your daydreaming maladaptive? I can’t answer that from personal experience. I’ve always had something in real life I cared about. But some people don’t. And if they find meaning in their daydreams, I can understand how it would be very difficult to keep their daydreaming under control.
[Photo by Francesco Ungaro]



