
People often ask “is it maladaptive daydreaming if I don’t create my own characters?”, “is it maladaptive daydreaming if I’m not in my daydreams?”, “is it maladaptive daydreaming if I don’t have a long-running plot”, etc. The answer in each case is the same: it depends how your daydreaming affects you.
Your daydreaming is only maladaptive if it harms you
As I’ve discussed elsewhere, your daydreaming is only maladaptive if it negatively affects other areas of your life. The proposed diagnostic criteria for maladaptive daydreaming say that daydreaming must cause “clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning”. If there is no distress or impairment, your daydreaming is not maladaptive. It’s that simple. What you daydream about doesn’t matter.
Immersive daydreaming isn’t harmful
Immersive daydreaming is exactly the same style of daydreaming as maladaptive daydreaming, but it doesn’t cause distress or impairment. So what do I mean by “same style of daydreaming”? Does immersive daydreaming have to have original characters or a long-running plot? Not necessarily. Immersive daydreaming is not well-defined in the academic literature, but I think of it as maladaptive daydreaming without the harm. Or, to flip it around, immersive daydreaming that causes distress or impairment becomes maladaptive daydreaming.
The proposed diagnostic criteria for maladaptive daydreaming are consistent with this definition. The first section lists eight features that distinguish maladaptive daydreaming from mind-wandering. It’s not necessary for someone with maladaptive daydreaming to have all eight – the first one plus at least one other is sufficient. Once someone meets the criteria in the first section, they then also need to meet the “distress or impairment” condition in the second section before a clinician will diagnose them with maladaptive daydreaming.
The eight items in the first section can be summarised as follows:
- An intense sense of absorption or immersion
- Daydreaming is triggered, maintained or enhanced by music.
- Daydreaming is triggered, maintained or enhanced by repetitive movement (e.g., pacing).
- Distress or boredom make daydreaming worse.
- Daydreaming is easier when alone.
- It’s annoying when daydreaming is interrupted.
- Daydreaming is preferable to social or professional activities.
- Daydreaming is difficult to control or stop.
All of the above, with the possible exception of the last one, apply to immersive daydreaming as well as maladaptive daydreaming, and serve to differentiate immersive daydreaming from mind-wandering (that thing that non-daydreamers often refer to as daydreaming).
None of the items in that list say anything about the content of your daydreams.
Daydreaming is about the experience, not the content
What immersive daydreaming and maladaptive daydreaming have in common is an experience. It’s an experience that’s difficult to put into words. If you have it, you know. It’s that ability to mentally transport yourself to another place. It’s about being so present in your imaginary world that you can describe every detail of what happens there. You know it isn’t real, but it evokes real emotions. In that imaginary world, you can craft a life of your choice. You might create your imaginary world anew each time you daydream, or you might refine and extend the same world over days, weeks or even years.
But what’s in that world doesn’t matter. It doesn’t even have to be a “world” in the sense of creating some kind of alternate reality. By “imaginary world”, I simply mean the place you go to in your imagination. It could be another planet, populated by mystical creatures, or it could be your office, populated by your boss and co-workers. It doesn’t matter. The point is, your imagination takes you somewhere and, for a little while, you exist there rather than here.
You can choose to daydream about anything you like
We daydreamers have the ability to imagine anything we choose. Some of us choose to invent magical or fantastical worlds, create fictional characters, or experiment with and refine a storyline that runs for years. But none of that is required, just as pacing and music aren’t always required.
Some daydreamers can’t daydream without music. I can’t daydream without creating fictional characters. But there are many daydreamers who do. They base their characters on people they know, or characters from a novel or TV show. And their daydreaming experience is just as valid as mine.
These days, I have a daydream self. There’s a character in my plot who is an idealised version of me. But as a child, I was never in my daydreams. I daydreamed about a group of characters who weren’t me. It didn’t mean my daydreams felt any less immersive.
What I want you to take away from this article is this. It is the quality of your daydreaming that differentiates immersive and maladaptive daydreaming from mind-wandering. And it’s the effect your daydreaming has on you that determines whether it’s immersive or maladaptive. The type of story you’re diving into is irrelevant. Whether you’re in your daydreams or not is irrelevant. Whether you create a new plot every day or keep the same one for a lifetime is irrelevant. Where your characters come from is irrelevant.
What happens in your imaginary world does not determine whether you’re a maladaptive daydreamer. That’s why, if your daydreaming is maladaptive, you can heal without giving up your characters or your worlds. You can daydream about exactly the same things as an immersive daydreamer as you do as a maladaptive daydreamer.
[Photo by Thuan Vo]



